What am I going on about? Compromise maybe…
Well imagine your fishing a long hooklink for the very good reason that the lake your angling on has a slightly silty scruffy lakebed and you lead somehow lands on a lovely clear spot the potential for the rig to be presented well is clear. The problem is, with all that ‘rope’, you’re also offering the carp ample opportunity to have enough rope to react and rid themselves of the hook.
If that rig had landed in the chod (as expected) then the extra resistance offered by the hooklink being sunk or entangled in debris on the bottom would actually create a circumstance where you long hooklink realistically reacts like a much shorter one.
The fine line between perfection and compromise is always a tricky one to meander along, but as carp anglers this is the skill that experience and knowledge imparts. When is it OK to shorten that hooklink right down and combine it with a dirty great chunk of inline lead? Is the lead really landing on a clean spot or is there a fine layer of sediment just thick enough to envelope and hide the carefully placed rig? Only experience (or a boat) can tell you…
To my mind, as a firmly rooted bank angler, it’s necessary to fish ‘bi-polar’ rigs. Sometimes you need to use something that will present ‘adequately’ over the majority of the lake bed with minimal casting whilst on other occasions the best results will come with precise spot angling, ensuring the hookbaits a inch perfect and the fish are given time to settle once more after the inevitable barrage of leads has subsided.
There are never any easy answers; all you can do is learn and develop as an angler – in the same way as terminal tackle, after all the two evolve side by side really don’t they. Look at hooks for instance. The performance of the patterns we have at our disposal today and the way they are broadly designed to work best with specific hook link materials is light years ahead of the comparatively blunt hooks that some of the great carpers used historically (imagine what they might have caught with a sharp hook!).
Now with hooks that are razor and the tools and the understanding to take them to another level so that an even higher percentage of carp that are snared see the inside of your landing net mesh. This revolution has been a progressive thing, but the introduction of certain tools naturally accelerates the wind of change and a cognitive leap will take place.
Hook points for instance. After the introduction of chemically sharpened points it didn’t seem like anything could come along that would genuinely improve on the perfection that we perceived. That was until anglers realised that it was possible to get a hook sharper if you could be bothered to practice and take your time to hone the hook too a point that is unlikely to be matched by any but the very best ‘1 in a 100’ hook…